North Carolina is one of the few states in the country that recognizes the contributory negligence rule. While most states follow the comparative negligence system (allowing an injured party to recover damages even if they are partially at fault), North Carolina’s contributory negligence law is much stricter. Also known as pure contributory negligence, the law allows an at-fault driver to avoid any financial liability to you after causing an accident if they can show that you were even 1% at fault for the accident. With such a low standard to avoid liability, car insurance companies can get very creative in coming up with arguments to suggest that you were at least 1% at fault.
Because North Carolina’s “1% rule” creates such a high stakes environment, having an experienced car accident attorney on your side is the best way to protect your rights. By speaking with a lawyer during a free consultation, you get expert advice on your case without any cost or risk. A lawyer can help prove the other driver was 100% at fault and stop the insurance company from unfairly blaming you to avoid paying what you deserve.
How Does Contributory Negligence Work?
Let’s explore a common scenario many people go through after a motor vehicle crash in North Carolina. Typically, the at-fault driver’s insurance company will call you after an accident and will ask to take your recorded statement. This is presented as “standard procedure”, so most people don’t see what is really going on. The insurance adjuster’s goal in taking your statement is to get something, anything, out of you that can be argued to suggest that you were at least 1% at fault for causing the accident. How do insurance companies typically build a contributory negligence argument to deny your claim? There are plenty of ways.
Common Ways Adjusters Use Contributory Negligence to Deny Car Insurance Claims
One common way car insurance companies use contributory negligence against you is by focusing on the timing of the crash. Since most people don’t have a stopwatch running before an accident, they often give the insurance adjuster “guesses” during a recorded statement. When you estimate that you saw the at-fault driver even a few seconds before the impact, the adjuster will use that against you. They will argue that you had enough time to avoid the accident if you had acted as a reasonable person would. Under North Carolina’s strict negligence rules, if they can prove you were even slightly negligent in those few seconds, you may be barred from recovering damages, and the at-fault party will not be held liable.
Denying Liability Based on the Timing of Events
You are sitting at a four way stop with traffic lights in all directions. You are stopped at a red light. Your light turns green, so you accelerate into the intersection. Once in the middle of the intersection, another driver runs a red light and hits the driver side of your car. Is the other driver at fault for running the red light and hitting you? Of course! However, the insurance adjuster will ask questions about whether you looked to see if their driver was approaching the intersection before you accelerated (even though you had the green light!). The insurance adjuster will also ask about your view of traffic approaching from their driver’s direction. How far could you have seen their driver had you looked that way before accelerating?
If the adjuster can take your answers and cobble together an argument that you had enough time to observe the at-fault driver (before the collision) and not hit him, they will probably deny your insurance claim. Even though the other driver ran a red light, and you waited for your green light before entering the intersection, the insurance company can refuse to pay your claim based on contributory negligence.
Denying Liability Based on Distance + Reaction Time
In this example, imagine you are driving down a two-lane road. There are solid yellow lines separating the two lanes of travel. This is a no passing zone. Another driver is headed toward you in the oncoming lane of travel. Even though this is a no passing zone, the other driver swings into your lane of travel and attempts to pass the car in front of him. In making this move, the other driver slams into the front of your car. Is the other driver at fault for attempting to pass over a double yellow line? Of course! So how will the adjuster try to use the 1% rule to deny your claim for damages?
The first thing the insurance adjuster might do is to try to box you in during a recorded statement. They will ask you questions about distances. “How far away was our insured driver when you first saw him cross the double yellow line”? The goal of the insurance adjuster is to put together an argument that there was sufficient distance between you and their insured driver that you could have swerved to avoid a collision. Huh? That’s right. The insurance company can tell you with a straight face that even though their driver was clearly at fault, that they will not agree to pay your car crash damages because, well, you should have gotten out of the way before their driver hit you!
Protect Your Rights After a North Carolina Car Accident
While the North Carolina contributory negligence law can lead to unfair results, you don’t have to face the insurance company alone. The best way to protect your claim is to work with an attorney from the very beginning. Once you start speaking with insurance adjusters on your own, you risk giving them the evidence they need to deny your claim.
If you want to ensure your rights are fully protected, contact Bradley Law Group for a free consultation before you speak with the insurance company. Let us handle the adjusters and help you avoid the “1% rule” trap so you can focus on your recovery.